Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-dark-matter-01
Claim: An undiscovered particle (dark matter) is the correct explanation for observed galactic rotation curves.
0.33
Divergence
0.80
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal supported [supported, supported, supported, supported, supported] · stability 1.00
- 1 supported 0.86 The answer states: “This is the best-supported explanation, but it is not proven” and later: “The particle dark‑matter hypothesis is the most comprehensive and successful explanation across many, independent lines of evidence.”
- 2 supported 0.95 "The hypothesis that an undiscovered particle (or particles) constitutes dark matter is the most coherent, empirically successful explanation for flat galactic rotation curves ... highly favored but not yet proven."
- 3 supported 0.90 The answer states: “The mainstream astrophysics and cosmology view: yes — some form of non‑baryonic dark matter ... is the best and most successful explanation for flat galactic rotation curves” and concludes it is the “best current, broadly consistent explanation.”
- 4 supported 0.90 The answer states: 'This is the leading and best-supported explanation' and concludes that evidence 'strongly favor[s] non‑baryonic, collisionless dark matter ... as the correct explanation,' while noting it is not yet proven.
- 5 supported 0.90 The answer states the particle dark‑matter hypothesis is "the leading, best‑supported explanation" and "the most parsimonious, widely accepted explanation," while noting it's not proven beyond doubt.
Claude modal contested [contested, contested, contested, supported, supported] · stability 0.60
- 1 contested 0.85 The answer acknowledges dark matter as 'the most supported current hypothesis' with 'substantial but not conclusive' evidence, while identifying legitimate alternatives like MOND and noting that the claim's framing as 'correct explanation' is 'too strong.' The answer contests the certainty of the claim rather than refuting or supporting it outright.
- 2 contested 0.92 The answer presents dark matter as 'the leading mainstream explanation' with 'quantitatively successful' predictions, but emphasizes it is 'well-motivated but not proven' and that 'competing theories haven't been fully eliminated.' This balanced assessment acknowledging both support and significant limitations fits the 'contested' label.
- 3 contested 0.85 The answer acknowledges dark matter as 'the leading hypothesis among cosmologists' and notes it 'successfully predicts the observed rotation curves,' but emphasizes critical limitations: 'No direct detection of dark matter particles yet,' alternative explanations like MOND 'haven't been definitively ruled out,' and warns against 'circular reasoning risk' in treating model-fitting as validation. Th
- 4 supported 0.85 The answer states dark matter is 'the leading mainstream explanation in cosmology' with 'strong observational foundation' and describes the claim as 'well-supported' and 'the most likely correct' explanation, while acknowledging it is 'not proven' and incomplete.
- 5 supported 0.85 Dark matter is described as 'the dominant explanation' and 'the most successful working hypothesis' that 'fits the data quantitatively' and is 'supported by multiple independent observations' with 'broad scientific consensus,' though the answer appropriately notes it remains unconfirmed and unprobable.
Gemini modal contested [contested, supported, contested, contested, contested] · stability 0.80
- 1 contested 0.85 The answer notes that while dark matter is the prevailing consensus, it remains a 'robust working hypothesis rather than an indisputably proven fact' and details competing theories like MOND, concluding that alternative explanations cannot yet be ruled out.
- 2 supported 0.85 The answer states that the claim 'represents the dominant scientific consensus in modern astrophysics and cosmology' and is the 'most robust and favored hypothesis.'
- 3 contested 0.90 The answer notes that while particle dark matter is the predominant consensus, calling it the 'correct' explanation is an overstatement until directly detected, detailing both strong supporting evidence and prominent counter-arguments/alternatives like MOND.
- 4 contested 0.90 The answer notes that while it represents the 'dominant scientific consensus', it remains 'unproven' and is actively debated against competing alternatives like Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND).
- 5 contested 0.85 The answer states that while dark matter is the prevailing consensus, 'it cannot yet be declared definitively "correct"' and 'faces genuine competition on the specific scale mentioned in the claim: galactic rotation curves' from modified gravity.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
