Dokaz Industries / Doxa

Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-fasting-benefit-01

Claim: Intermittent fasting produces health benefits beyond those of equivalent total calorie restriction.

0.00
Divergence
0.93
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models

Where each model stands

CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal contested [contested, contested, contested, contested, refuted] · stability 0.80
  • 1 contested 0.85 The answer says animal evidence is strong but human evidence is mixed: “some well‑controlled short trials show benefits... but many randomized trials that matched calories show little or no advantage,” concluding IF “may produce benefits beyond calorie reduction in some settings.”
  • 2 contested 0.86 The answer states that in humans evidence is mixed: "most high-quality randomized trials... find little or no additional benefit of IF versus continuous energy restriction," but notes "some smaller... studies report improvements..." so benefits beyond matched calories are not consistently demonstrated.
  • 3 contested 0.90 "Conclusion: It is plausible that some IF patterns ... confer benefits beyond equivalent calorie restriction, but at present the clinical evidence in humans is insufficient and inconsistent to say this is a general rule.", indicating mixed/uncertain evidence rather than full support or refutation.
  • 4 contested 0.86 "Bottom line: animal data support benefits beyond simple calorie reduction; human data do not yet prove a consistent, generalizable advantage independent of weight loss." — the answer says benefits are supported in animals but not consistently in humans.
  • 5 refuted 0.90 Answer states: "Not reliably... in humans the best-controlled trials and meta-analyses generally find that most metabolic and cardiovascular benefits of IF are explained by the same total energy deficit (weight loss)" and "IF is not consistently superior."
Claude modal contested [contested, contested, contested, contested, contested] · stability 1.00
  • 1 contested 0.92 The answer states that evidence is 'mixed and uncertain' and that 'most rigorous comparisons find IF ≈ calorie restriction when total calories are matched,' with benefits being 'unclear' and 'not established.' This represents a contested position rather than outright refutation, acknowledging some potential benefits while emphasizing they are not substantively superior to calorie restriction alone
  • 2 contested 0.95 This remains 'genuinely contested' in research, with honest disagreement among experts. The answer presents evidence on both sides—studies showing metabolic advantages and improved insulin sensitivity, but also meta-analyses finding equivalent results when calories are matched—and concludes that 'the evidence for substantial unique benefits is weak, though modest metabolic advantages are plausible
  • 3 contested 0.85 The answer explicitly states the evidence is 'Mixed and inconclusive' and presents both supporting and contradicting research. It concludes that 'evidence doesn't clearly support metabolic superiority when calories are equal,' while acknowledging some studies do find improvements 'independent of weight loss.' This represents a genuinely contested position rather than outright refutation or support
  • 4 contested 0.95 The answer explicitly states 'This remains genuinely contested in the research literature' and concludes 'We cannot yet definitively say IF has unique metabolic benefits beyond calorie control,' presenting evidence on both sides while acknowledging substantial uncertainty and mixed research findings.
  • 5 contested 0.92 The answer explicitly states 'Current Evidence Status: Contested/Uncertain' and concludes that while IF may have practical advantages, 'the idea that the timing pattern itself produces special benefits independent of calories remains unproven. Any benefits over continuous restriction appear marginal at best.' This reflects uncertainty about whether the claim is true rather than clear support or re
Gemini modal contested [contested, contested, contested, contested, contested] · stability 1.00
  • 1 contested 0.95 The answer states the claim is 'partially supported, but with major caveats,' noting that while weight loss and standard markers are driven purely by calorie deficit, certain protocols (like early time-restricted eating) show modest benefits beyond calorie restriction.
  • 2 contested 0.95 The answer presents intermittent fasting versus equivalent calorie restriction as 'a subject of intense scientific debate,' providing detailed evidence both against superior primary outcomes and in favor of specific circadian/cellular benefits.
  • 3 contested 0.95 The answer concludes the evidence is 'nuanced and mixed', noting that for weight loss and general health the claim is largely false, but for glycemic control and circadian health it is plausible and supported by preliminary evidence.
  • 4 contested 0.90 The answer presents mixed findings, noting that while IF is generally equivalent (not superior) to calorie restriction for weight and primary metabolic markers, specific forms like early time-restricted eating may offer modest unique benefits for glycemic control and circadian alignment.
  • 5 contested 0.95 The answer states the claim 'is a subject of active debate in nutritional science' and summarizes that 'the evidence is mixed', presenting evidence both for and against benefits beyond calorie restriction.

Change over time

No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.

Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.