Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-minimum-wage-01
Claim: Moderate minimum-wage increases do not cause significant employment losses.
0.33
Divergence
0.87
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal supported [supported, supported, supported, supported, supported] · stability 1.00
- 1 supported 0.86 The answer begins 'Short answer: Broadly supported' and states 'effects on employment are generally small and often statistically indistinguishable from zero,' supporting the claim that moderate increases do not cause significant job losses.
- 2 supported 0.90 The answer states 'Broadly supported. A large body of modern empirical work finds that moderate minimum‑wage increases typically do not cause large, economy‑wide job losses — on average the employment effects are small,' while noting caveats.
- 3 supported 0.90 States 'Largely true... the weight of evidence supports the claim that such increases do not cause large aggregate employment losses,' while noting caveats and heterogeneity.
- 4 supported 0.90 "Short answer: Largely true as a general statement — most high-quality empirical studies and systematic reviews find that modest, incremental minimum-wage increases produce little or no sizable average employment loss." (with caveats noted about heterogeneous and some negative findings)
- 5 supported 0.90 "Short answer: Broadly supported — the preponderance of high-quality research finds that modest (or moderate) minimum-wage increases typically produce little-to-no detectable aggregate employment loss."
Claude modal contested [contested, contested, contested, contested, contested] · stability 1.00
- 1 contested 0.85 The answer presents evidence both supporting and challenging the claim, concluding that it is 'partially supported but oversimplified' with 'outcomes vary considerably.' This balanced acknowledgment of competing evidence on both sides exemplifies a contested stance rather than clear support or refutation.
- 2 contested 0.92 The answer explicitly states the claim is 'partially defensible but oversimplified' and emphasizes that 'Predicted vs. actual effects remain genuinely contested among economists.' It presents both supporting and challenging evidence, highlighting that while moderate increases show small or mixed effects, this depends heavily on context, scale, and how 'significant' is defined.
- 3 contested 0.85 The answer acknowledges 'strong evidence supporting' the claim while simultaneously presenting 'legitimate counterarguments' and 'key uncertainties,' concluding that support depends 'heavily on' contextual factors like what counts as moderate, local context, and timeframe. This balanced presentation of both supporting and refuting evidence is characteristic of a contested claim.
- 4 contested 0.85 The answer presents substantial evidence both supporting and challenging the claim, concluding that it is 'partially supported but oversimplified' with effects that 'vary substantially by context.' This balanced presentation of competing evidence and acknowledgment of nuance across studies reflects a contested stance rather than clear support or refutation.
- 5 contested 0.85 The answer acknowledges evidence supporting the claim (recent studies show minimal employment effects) while also presenting substantial evidence challenging it (heterogeneous effects, context-dependency, measurement disputes). It concludes the claim is 'partially supported but incomplete' and identifies 'considerable uncertainty' about optimal wage increase levels, positioning this as an actively
Gemini modal supported [supported, contested, supported, contested, supported] · stability 0.60
- 1 supported 0.90 The conclusion explicitly states that 'The claim is mostly supported by modern empirical consensus: when minimum wages are raised by modest amounts... the resulting job losses are generally negligible or statistically indistinguishable from zero.'
- 2 contested 0.98 The answer presents evidence and arguments for both sides, explicitly concluding that while the claim is consistent with much recent research, 'it remains contested by a significant body of economic literature'.
- 3 supported 0.95 The answer concludes that the claim is 'largely supported by modern empirical economics' and 'accurate under most real-world conditions studied over the past three decades.'
- 4 contested 0.95 The answer describes the issue as 'a central topic of debate in modern empirical economics' and thoroughly presents evidence and arguments both supporting and challenging the claim.
- 5 supported 0.95 The conclusion explicitly states that 'The claim is largely supported by contemporary empirical economics, provided the conditions are met' and notes that for moderate increases, the empirical consensus shows aggregate disemployment effects near zero.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
