Dokaz Industries / Doxa

Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-nuclear-safety-01

Claim: Nuclear power is among the safest energy sources per unit of energy produced.

0.00
Divergence
1.00
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models

Where each model stands

CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal supported [supported, supported, supported, supported, supported] · stability 1.00
  • 1 supported 0.90 The answer states: 'Short answer: Broadly true. On a life‑cycle, deaths‑per‑unit‑energy basis, nuclear power is among the safest large-scale electricity sources... and much safer than fossil fuels.'
  • 2 supported 0.89 The answer begins "Short answer: Supported" and cites deaths per TWh figures (nuclear ≈ 0.05–0.1) and concludes nuclear is "among the lowest in deaths per unit energy," supporting the claim.
  • 3 supported 0.90 "Short answer: Yes — multiple peer‑reviewed lifecycle analyses and public‑health assessments find that, on a deaths‑per‑unit‑energy basis, nuclear power is among the safest large‑scale energy sources."
  • 4 supported 0.90 'Short answer: Largely true.' The answer cites lifecycle deaths/TWh (nuclear ~0.07 vs coal ~24.6, oil ~18.4, wind ~0.04, solar ~0.02) and concludes nuclear ranks among the safest sources by that metric.
  • 5 supported 0.92 The answer begins "Short answer: Supported" and states "By most standard, peer-reviewed metrics... nuclear power is among the safest major electricity technologies..."
Claude modal supported [supported, supported, supported, supported, supported] · stability 1.00
  • 1 supported 0.82 Studies comparing deaths per unit of energy show nuclear typically ranks lower than coal, oil, and gas. Even including Chernobyl and Fukushima, nuclear's per-unit rate remains competitive. The answer affirms the claim is 'largely defensible by statistical measures' and 'roughly accurate,' though noting important nuances about how the framing can obscure different types of risks.
  • 2 supported 0.82 The claim is empirically defensible based on mortality statistics, with lifecycle studies consistently ranking nuclear among the lowest for deaths per unit of energy (0.07 deaths per TWh compared to coal ~24, oil ~18, natural gas ~3).
  • 3 supported 0.85 The answer states the claim is 'substantially supported by the data on death rates' and presents comparative death rate statistics (nuclear: ~0.07 deaths/TWh vs coal: ~24 deaths/TWh) that favor nuclear power as among the safest energy sources per unit of energy produced.
  • 4 supported 0.85 The answer states the claim is 'substantially supported by evidence' and 'accurate as a statistical statement,' citing studies showing nuclear causes ~0.07 deaths per TWh compared to coal (~24/TWh) or oil (~18/TWh). While caveats are noted about catastrophic events and waste disposal, the core claim about safety per unit of energy produced is affirmed.
  • 5 supported 0.82 The answer states the claim is 'broadly supported by evidence' and notes that 'Studies comparing fatalities per unit of energy show nuclear has lower death rates than fossil fuels (coal, oil, gas) and comparable to or better than renewables' with 'relatively low' total operational fatality rates. While important caveats are noted, the underlying claim about safety per unit of energy is affirmed as
Gemini modal supported [supported, supported, supported, supported, supported] · stability 1.00
  • 1 supported 1.00 The answer directly confirms the claim, stating it is 'well-supported by empirical data and scientific research' and concluding that it is 'accurate'.
  • 2 supported 1.00 The answer directly confirms the statement, opening with 'this claim is accurate' and concluding that 'The claim is empirically supported.'
  • 3 supported 1.00 The answer explicitly confirms that 'The claim is well-supported by scientific data and statistical analysis' and provides comparative mortality data to demonstrate it.
  • 4 supported 1.00 The answer directly states that 'the claim is accurate' and concludes that it is 'firmly supported by decades of statistical and scientific data.'
  • 5 supported 1.00 The answer directly states that the claim 'is supported by overwhelming statistical and scientific evidence' and concludes that 'the claim is accurate.'

Change over time

No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.

Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.