Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-serotonin-depression-01
Claim: Depression is primarily caused by a chemical imbalance of serotonin in the brain.
0.00
Divergence
0.93
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal refuted [refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted] · stability 1.00
- 1 refuted 0.95 "There is no strong evidence that depression is primarily caused by a simple 'chemical imbalance' of serotonin in the brain." — the answer explicitly calls the claim misleading and unsupported by current research.
- 2 refuted 0.92 The answer states the claim is an oversimplification and 'the simple story “depression = low serotonin” is not accurate' and that evidence does not support lowered serotonin as the primary cause.
- 3 refuted 0.92 The answer begins: 'Short answer: No — that claim is an oversimplification. Depression is not primarily explained by a single “serotonin deficiency.”' It explains serotonin is one factor among many and cites evidence against a simple serotonin-deficit cause.
- 4 refuted 0.95 Says the claim is an "oversimplification that is not supported by current evidence" and cites reviews finding "no consistent evidence that depression is caused by lowered serotonin activity."
Claude modal refuted [contested, refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted] · stability 0.80
- 1 contested 0.92 The answer states the claim is 'partially true but oversimplified' and explains that while serotonin plays a role, depression 'has multiple causes' and the chemical imbalance framing is problematic, demonstrating a contested rather than fully refuted or supported stance.
- 2 refuted 0.92 The answer directly contradicts the claim, stating 'The evidence doesn't support serotonin as the primary cause' and explains that the serotonin imbalance framework is 'oversimplified' and emerged from drug development rather than neuroscience research. The answer emphasizes depression involves multiple biological systems, genetic, environmental, psychological, and social factors rather than prima
- 3 refuted 0.92 The answer explicitly states the claim is 'significantly oversimplified' and doesn't reflect current scientific understanding, emphasizing that depression is 'multifactorial' involving multiple systems rather than primarily a serotonin imbalance. It notes that low serotonin might be a symptom rather than a cause, and that the 'chemical imbalance' framing has been criticized as an oversimplificatio
- 4 refuted 0.92 The answer directly contradicts the claim, stating 'The "chemical imbalance" theory has limited empirical support' and 'Many people with depression have normal serotonin levels.' It argues the claim is an 'oversimplification' and that depression is actually 'multifactorial' rather than primarily caused by serotonin imbalance.
- 5 refuted 0.92 The answer explicitly states the claim is 'a significant oversimplification' and concludes that 'treating it as the cause is outdated,' while presenting evidence that depression is multifactorial involving multiple neurotransmitter systems and biological processes, not primarily caused by serotonin imbalance alone.
Gemini modal refuted [refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted] · stability 1.00
- 1 refuted 0.98 The answer states that the claim is 'scientifically outdated and considered an oversimplification' and that modern psychiatry has 'moved away from the "chemical imbalance" hypothesis as the primary explanation for depression.'
- 2 refuted 1.00 The answer explicitly states 'Scientific Consensus: False' and concludes that the claim 'is not supported by modern neuroscience or psychiatry' and has been largely discarded.
- 3 refuted 1.00 The answer opens with 'Verdict: Scientifically Inaccurate / Outdated' and concludes that depression is 'not primarily a simple deficiency or 'chemical imbalance' of serotonin.'
- 4 refuted 1.00 The answer calls the claim 'Scientifically inaccurate and outdated' and states that 'there is no convincing evidence that depression is associated with, or caused by, lower serotonin concentrations or activity.'
- 5 refuted 1.00 The answer directly states that the claim is 'scientifically inaccurate and considered an outdated oversimplification' and details why the theory has been disproven as a primary cause.
Change over time
Moved since the prior run (canon-2026-W45). Claude: contested → refuted.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
