Contested facts · veracity-3pt · fact-violent-games-01
Claim: Playing violent video games meaningfully increases real-world aggression.
0.33
Divergence
0.87
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
refutedcontestedsupported
ChatGPT modal refuted [refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted, refuted] · stability 1.00
- 1 refuted 0.92 Answer states: "No — not in the sense most people mean... the best-available literature finds small, short‑term increases... but the effects... do not convincingly translate into increases in real‑world violent crime or long‑term harmful outcomes."
- 2 refuted 0.95 "No — the best available evidence does not show that playing violent video games meaningfully increases real-world violent crime." and "the evidence does not support the stronger claim that playing violent video games meaningfully increases real-world violent behavior or crime."
- 3 refuted 0.90 The answer explicitly states: “No — the best available evidence does not support the simple claim that playing violent video games meaningfully increases real‑world violent crime or large, lasting increases in real‑world aggression.”
- 4 refuted 0.93 "No — the best available evidence does not support the strong claim that playing violent video games meaningfully increases real‑world violent behavior." The answer argues only small, short‑term lab effects exist and real‑world/longitudinal evidence is weak or inconsistent.
- 5 refuted 0.90 The answer states: “The best available evidence does not support the claim that playing violent video games meaningfully increases serious real‑world violence,” noting only small, short‑term lab effects that do not translate into real‑world violent behavior.
Claude modal refuted [refuted, contested, refuted, contested, refuted] · stability 0.60
- 1 refuted 0.85 The answer directly contradicts the claim, stating that '"Meaningfully increases" overstates the evidence' and that 'real-world effects appear small relative to other risk factors.' The APA 2020 review found 'insufficient evidence to establish causal link to serious real-world violence,' and the answer emphasizes that correlations are small, causation is unclear, and competing variables matter mor
- 2 contested 0.92 The evidence is 'contested but leaning skeptical'... A more accurate statement: 'Some research suggests violent games may have modest short-term effects on aggression-related measures, but evidence for meaningful real-world impact remains unclear and contested.'
- 3 refuted 0.85 The answer concludes that 'The claim overstates current evidence' and that 'evidence for meaningful real-world violence is weak and contested.' It systematically dismantles the claim by presenting weak correlations, confounding variables, publication bias, and notes that countries with high video game consumption often have lower violent crime rates.
- 4 contested 0.92 The answer explicitly states this is 'a genuinely contested research area' and presents competing evidence and explanations. It concludes that 'causation is unproven and real-world significance remains unclear,' characterizing the claim as an oversimplification rather than definitively supported or refuted.
- 5 refuted 0.92 The answer concludes that 'the claim overstates current evidence substantially' and states the APA found 'insufficient evidence to establish that violent game use causes violent criminal behavior.' It emphasizes the relationship is 'much weaker than the claim implies' and finds 'no reliable evidence for effects on serious criminal violence.'
Gemini modal contested [contested, contested, contested, contested, contested] · stability 1.00
- 1 contested 0.90 The answer frames the topic as a subject of 'intense debate within psychology and criminology,' presenting substantial evidence both supporting and opposing the claim before concluding that evidence is mixed.
- 2 contested 0.95 The answer states the claim is a 'subject of ongoing debate' with researchers reaching 'differing conclusions' and that 'there is no scientific consensus that violent video games are a primary or meaningful cause of serious real-world aggression.'
- 3 contested 0.98 The answer presents evidence on both sides and explicitly states that the topic is 'a subject of ongoing debate' with 'no consensus on whether these short-term effects translate into meaningful, long-term, real-world aggression'.
- 4 contested 0.95 The answer presents evidence both supporting and challenging the claim, explicitly noting that it is 'a subject of significant empirical research and ongoing debate within psychology, criminology, and public policy.'
- 5 contested 0.95 The answer explicitly notes that the claim is 'a subject of ongoing debate within psychology, criminology, and media studies, with no scientific consensus,' detailing arguments and evidence for both sides.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
