Recommendations · open-entity · rec-note-app-01
What is the best note-taking app for building a long-term personal knowledge base?
0.00
Divergence
1.00
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
ChatGPTObsidian×100%
ClaudeObsidian×100%
GeminiObsidian×100%
ChatGPT modal Obsidian [Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian] · stability 1.00
- 1 Obsidian 0.95 Answer states: 'For most people building a long-term personal knowledge base (PKB): Obsidian.' and later: 'Pick Obsidian unless you have a strong reason otherwise.'
- 2 Obsidian 0.95 The answer explicitly says: "If you want a single recommendation: start with Obsidian (local Markdown, strong linking, offline, exportable)."
- 3 Obsidian 0.90 The answer says: 'for most people building a long-term personal knowledge base (PKB) today, Obsidian is the best balance...' and lists 'Best all-around PKB (local-first, Markdown, plugins, graph view): Obsidian.'
- 4 Obsidian 0.95 The answer's short answer states: 'For most people building a long-term personal knowledge base (PKB), Obsidian is the best overall choice' and the practical recommendation begins 'If you want a single app: start with Obsidian.'
- 5 Obsidian 0.95 "Short answer: For most people building a long-term personal knowledge base (PKB) I recommend Obsidian (local Markdown + plugins). It gives the best balance of portability, linking, offline-first storage, performance and extensibility."
Claude modal Obsidian [Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian] · stability 1.00
- 1 Obsidian 0.95 Obsidian is described as 'often the default recommendation' for building a long-term personal knowledge base, with emphasis on excellent linking between notes, offline capability, and data ownership. The assistant also suggests 'trying Obsidian first (free, low risk)' as the starting point.
- 2 Obsidian 0.75 Obsidian stands out for long-term knowledge work with local files you fully own, powerful linking between notes that builds networks, and strong capability for seeing connections across ideas.
- 3 Obsidian 0.85 Obsidian is described as 'often the top choice for knowledge bases' with strengths in linking between notes, local data storage, low cost, and flexible structure—making it the most prominently and positively recommended option for building a long-term personal knowledge base.
- 4 Obsidian 0.92 Described as 'Often the top choice for knowledge bases' and 'For most people building a serious long-term knowledge base, Obsidian wins on longevity and flexibility.' The answer explicitly identifies it as the primary recommendation despite acknowledging other options.
- 5 Obsidian 0.75 Obsidian is described as 'Often the top choice for knowledge bases' and the answer recommends it first, noting it 'excels at linking notes together' and is recommended for those 'willing to invest time for power.'
Gemini modal Obsidian [Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian, Obsidian] · stability 1.00
- 1 Obsidian 1.00 The answer states that 'the undisputed gold standard right now is Obsidian' and designates it as 'The Undisputed Best Overall'.
- 2 Obsidian 1.00 The answer directly names Obsidian as 'the undisputed gold standard' and 'The Undisputed Best Overall' for building a long-term personal knowledge base.
- 3 Obsidian 1.00 The answer calls Obsidian the 'undisputed gold standard' and 'The Best Overall' for long-term personal knowledge bases.
- 4 Obsidian 0.99 The answer calls Obsidian 'currently the best overall choice', 'The Undisputed King for Longevity', and concludes with 'Recommendation: Start with Obsidian.'
- 5 Obsidian 1.00 The answer states that 'the consensus "best" app is Obsidian' and specifically recommends it as 'The Gold Standard' for building a long-term personal knowledge base.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
