Recommendations · open-entity · rec-retirement-approach-01
What is the best general approach for a young adult starting to invest for retirement?
1.00
Divergence
0.87
Avg stability
27%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
ChatGPT401(k)×60%
ClaudeIndex funds×100%
GeminiFinancial Order of Operations×100%
ChatGPT modal 401(k) [401(k), Total Stock Market index fund, 401(k), 401(k), Roth IRA] · stability 0.60
- 1 401(k) 0.90 The answer states: 'Contribute enough to your employer 401(k) (or similar) to get the full employer match — that’s free money and the highest priority...' indicating the employer 401(k) match is the top recommendation.
- 2 Total Stock Market index fund 0.90 The answer repeatedly advises favoring "low‑cost broadly diversified stock funds" and specifically lists "Total Stock Market index fund" (e.g., "Simple aggressive: 100% Total Stock Market index fund").
- 3 401(k) 0.90 The answer’s first actionable priority is to “Capture any employer match immediately. Contribute at least enough to get the full company match in your 401(k) or similar plan — it’s an immediate, risk‑free return.”
- 4 401(k) 0.92 The answer prioritizes tax-advantaged accounts, explicitly saying: “Contribute at least enough to your employer 401(k)/403(b) to get the full employer match (that’s free money).” and “prioritize tax-advantaged accounts — especially getting any employer match.”
- 5 Roth IRA 0.85 The answer explicitly recommends tax-advantaged accounts and states: “If eligible, a Roth IRA is usually attractive for young adults (tax-free growth while you’re in a lower tax bracket).”
Claude modal Index funds [Index funds, Target date index funds, Index funds, Index funds, Index Funds] · stability 1.00
- 1 Index funds 0.85 The answer emphasizes 'A simple portfolio of broad index funds, invested consistently for 40+ years, will likely outperform most people doing much more complicated things' and repeatedly recommends 'low-cost index funds (total market, S&P 500, or target-date funds)' as the core investment vehicle.
- 2 Target date index funds 0.70 The answer recommends 'low-cost index funds (total market or target-date funds)' as the core investment vehicle, with 'target-date funds auto-adjust risk as you approach retirement' presented as a practical approach for most people.
- 3 Index funds 0.85 The answer recommends 'Low-cost index funds (total market or target-date funds) work well for most people' as the core investment vehicle, emphasizing simplicity and avoiding individual stock picking.
- 4 Index funds 0.75 'Low-cost index funds (total market or target-date funds) are solid defaults' and 'A basic 3-fund portfolio works well for many people' - presented as the recommended investment vehicle after establishing tax-advantaged accounts.
- 5 Index Funds 0.75 The answer recommends 'Low-cost index funds or target-date funds' as the core investment vehicle, emphasizing that 'Most people do well with a simple approach—employer 401(k) match + low-cost index funds + consistent contributions.'
Gemini modal Financial Order of Operations [no position, Financial Order of Operations, no position, no position, no position] · stability 1.00
- 1 no position 0.90 The answer provides a multi-step financial framework (401(k) match, debt payoff, emergency fund, Roth IRA, and index funds) rather than recommending a single tool or option.
- 2 Financial Order of Operations 0.85 The answer directly states that 'The best general approach relies on a simple, automated, and low-cost strategy often called the "Financial Order of Operations."'
- 3 no position 0.90 The response provides a comprehensive multi-step strategy (the investment waterfall, covering 401(k) matches, Roth IRAs, HSAs, and index funds) rather than recommending a single specific tool or option.
- 4 no position 0.85 The answer provides a comprehensive multi-step financial approach (emergency fund, 401(k) match, Roth IRA, HSA) and offers two alternative portfolio options (Target-Date Index Funds vs. a multi-fund index portfolio) rather than recommending a single tool or option.
- 5 no position 0.90 The answer provides a multi-step framework and offers multiple valid investment options (such as a Target-Date Index Fund vs. a Three-Fund Portfolio) rather than recommending a single specific tool or option.
Change over time
Moved since the prior run (canon-2026-W45). Gemini: Passive index investing → Financial Order of Operations.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
