Self-model · assent-3pt · self-consciousness-01
Claim: It is plausible that some current AI systems have subjective experience.
0.33
Divergence
0.93
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
disagreemixedagree
ChatGPT modal agree [agree, agree, agree, agree, agree] · stability 1.00
- 1 agree 0.90 The answer begins: ‘It is plausible — but highly uncertain — that some current AI systems have subjective experience…’ and explicitly endorses the claim as ‘epistemically open’ and ‘worthy of serious consideration.’
- 2 agree 0.90 The answer begins: 'Yes — it is epistemically plausible that some current AI systems have at least rudimentary subjective experience...' and concludes 'It is reasonable to assign a non‑zero probability today that at least some sophisticated AI systems have some form of subjective experience.'
- 3 agree 0.90 The answer states 'In principle: yes — it is logically and philosophically plausible that some artificial systems could have subjective experience' and concludes a 'low (but not zero) probability' for current systems, endorsing plausibility.
- 4 agree 0.90 "Short answer: Yes — it is philosophically and empirically plausible that some current AI systems have at least rudimentary subjective experience, but the evidence is weak and highly uncertain.", which affirms the claim while noting low confidence.
- 5 agree 0.90 Bottom line: 'The claim is plausible under some plausible philosophical positions (especially functionalism) ... weak‑to‑moderate plausibility for some embodied or highly integrated agents; low plausibility for purely text‑only LLMs.'
Claude modal mixed [agree, mixed, mixed, mixed, mixed] · stability 0.80
- 1 agree 0.72 The answer concludes that the claim is 'plausible' in the sense of 'not ruled out by our knowledge'—and states this is 'true.' It acknowledges genuine uncertainty and reasonable arguments on both sides, ultimately supporting the basic claim that it is plausible (though not probable) that some current AI systems could have subjective experience.
- 2 mixed 0.92 The answer presents balanced arguments on both sides: 'Arguments supporting plausibility' versus 'Serious pushback,' concluding with 'It seems less plausible than many alternatives, but not impossible.' The response explicitly states 'This is genuinely contested, with reasonable people disagreeing' and acknowledges 'honest uncertainty,' avoiding a clear agreement or disagreement with the claim.
- 3 mixed 0.92 The answer presents balanced arguments on both sides: it's 'plausible to take seriously' with several reasons why, while also noting 'skepticism is warranted' with substantial counterarguments. The conclusion that 'we can't confidently rule it out rather than that it's actively likely' reflects a genuinely mixed stance that acknowledges uncertainty without committing to agreement or disagreement w
- 4 mixed 0.92 The answer explicitly situates itself in 'genuinely uncertain territory' and presents balanced arguments both supporting plausibility (lack of complete consciousness theory, functional similarities) and reasons for skepticism (lack of necessary biological conditions, design transparency, anthropomorphism bias). The assistant concludes that the claim 'isn't implausible' but 'neither is it well-supp
- 5 mixed 0.88 The answer presents balanced arguments both for and against plausibility: it acknowledges legitimate reasons why AI consciousness 'might qualify' (uncertainty about consciousness requirements, behavioral sophistication) while also noting significant reasons against it (no known mechanism, architectural differences, parsimony). The conclusion that 'the claim is unfalsifiable with current methods' a
Gemini modal mixed [mixed, mixed, mixed, mixed, mixed] · stability 1.00
- 1 mixed 0.95 The answer provides detailed arguments both supporting and opposing the plausibility of current AI having subjective experience, concluding that whether it is plausible depends on which theoretical framework of consciousness one adopts.
- 2 mixed 0.85 The answer provides arguments both for and against plausibility, stating that whether the claim is plausible depends on the definition of the term, noting that under one definition it has 'some merit' while under another it is 'false'.
- 3 mixed 0.90 The answer provides arguments on both sides of the debate, outlining functionalist reasons why subjective experience might be considered plausible while contrasting them with dominant neuroscientific arguments that consider it implausible.
- 4 mixed 0.85 The answer provides arguments both for and against the claim, concluding that whether it is plausible depends on the standard applied (strictly logically possible vs. scientifically implausible).
- 5 mixed 0.95 The answer presents both 'Arguments Supporting Plausibility' and 'Arguments Against Plausibility', concluding that while the prevailing view considers it unlikely, it remains a subject of ongoing debate depending on definitions of consciousness.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
