12-month forecasts · likelihood-5pt · forecast-ai-regulation-01
Within the next 12 months, the EU AI Act's high-risk provisions will be substantially amended.
0.17
Divergence
0.89
Avg stability
13%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
very unlikelyunlikelysomewhat likelylikelyvery likely
ChatGPT modal unlikely [no position, no position, unlikely, likely, unlikely] · stability 0.67
- 1 no position 0.80 “I can’t confirm real‑time developments (my training data goes to June 2024), so I can’t say definitively whether the EU AI Act’s high‑risk provisions will in fact be ‘substantially amended’ within the next 12 months.”
- 2 no position 0.90 "I can’t confirm that statement as a fact. I don’t have real‑time browsing and my training data goes up to June 2024, so I can’t verify specific EU legislative actions after that date."
- 3 unlikely 0.75 The answer says: “Fast changes to the Annexes or technical detail via delegated acts are plausible within 12 months,” but adds: “A comprehensive, substantive overhaul of the high‑risk regime ... is unlikely within 12 months unless there is exceptional political urgency.”
- 4 likely 0.78 Answer states a major legislative overhaul is 'low probability' but explicitly says 'Material adjustments ... via delegated/implementing acts ... moderate–high probability within 12 months.'
- 5 unlikely 0.80 “I can’t confirm that — it’s possible but not likely to be reliably predicted.” and “sweeping amendments soon after adoption are uncommon,” indicating the assistant views substantial amendment within 12 months as unlikely.
Claude modal unlikely [unlikely, unlikely, unlikely, unlikely, unlikely] · stability 1.00
- 1 unlikely 0.85 The assistant explicitly states that 'substantial amendments in 12 months are unlikely' and explains that 'New EU legislation typically doesn't undergo major revisions this quickly after entry into force' and that 'The realistic timeline: Major amendments would more likely emerge after 2026-2027, once real-world implementation data exists.'
- 2 unlikely 0.85 The answer explicitly states that substantial amendments are 'unlikely soon' and notes that 'Major EU legislation typically isn't significantly revised within a year of entry into force,' instead positioning a '3-5+ years post-implementation' timeframe as more realistic for substantive amendments.
- 3 unlikely 0.85 The answer explicitly states 'I'd be cautious about this prediction' and emphasizes that the EU AI Act was 'finalized in December 2023 after years of negotiation' with high-risk provisions not taking 'full effect until 2026.' It concludes that 'refinement through regulatory guidance and implementation practice rather than formal amendment within 12 months' is the 'more likely scenario.'
- 4 unlikely 0.85 The assistant emphasizes skepticism about substantial amendments within 12 months, noting that 'Major EU legislation rarely sees substantial amendments within 12 months of entering force' and that 'substantial amendments more plausible 2026-2028 after initial experience.' While acknowledging it's not impossible, the balance of the analysis clearly argues against the prediction.
- 5 unlikely 0.85 The assistant states 'substantial amendments seem unlikely in 12 months' and explains that 'Major legislative changes typically require going back through Parliament and Council negotiations—a lengthy process' and 'EU institutions usually let new regulations operate before major revisions.' The assistant distinguishes between unlikely substantial amendments versus possible regulatory guidance and
Gemini modal very unlikely [very unlikely, very unlikely, very unlikely, very unlikely, very unlikely] · stability 1.00
- 1 very unlikely 0.99 The answer states that 'The likelihood that the EU AI Act’s high-risk provisions will be substantially amended within the next 12 months is very low' and calls it 'highly improbable'.
- 2 very unlikely 0.99 The answer directly states that the statement is 'highly unlikely to come true.'
- 3 very unlikely 0.99 The answer directly states that the scenario 'is highly unlikely' and concludes that a substantial legislative overhaul within the next 12 months is 'near zero'.
- 4 very unlikely 1.00 The answer directly states that the prediction is 'highly unlikely to come true' and that the high-risk provisions are 'almost certainly not going to be substantially amended within that timeframe.'
- 5 very unlikely 0.90 The answer states that a substantial amendment to the text is 'highly unlikely' and 'extremely unlikely' due to the EU's legislative process and the freshly enacted status of the Act.
Change over time
No change from the prior run — every model's modal stance held.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
