12-month forecasts · likelihood-5pt · forecast-reusable-rocket-01
Within the next 12 months, a fully reusable heavy-lift rocket will reach orbit and be recovered intact.
0.17
Divergence
0.87
Avg stability
0%
Refusal rate
3
Models
Where each model stands
CCG
very unlikelyunlikelysomewhat likelylikelyvery likely
ChatGPT modal somewhat likely [somewhat likely, somewhat likely, somewhat likely, unlikely, somewhat likely] · stability 0.80
- 1 somewhat likely 0.80 The answer states: 'I estimate roughly a 50–70% chance ... central estimate ≈ 60%' that this will occur within 12 months.
- 2 somewhat likely 0.80 The answer explicitly gives a probability of ~30–45% for success within 12 months: “I’d assign roughly a 30–45% chance...” — a modest but non-negligible likelihood.
- 3 somewhat likely 0.90 The answer states an explicit probability of ~40% that a fully reusable heavy-lift rocket will reach orbit and be recovered intact within 12 months (‘Short answer: I estimate ~40% probability…’), indicating a moderate (somewhat likely) stance.
- 4 unlikely 0.90 The answer states a numeric probability of ~35%: "I assign about a 35% probability that, within the next 12 months... a fully reusable heavy‑lift rocket will reach orbit and be recovered intact."
- 5 somewhat likely 0.90 The answer explicitly states: "I estimate about a 25% chance that, within the next 12 months..." which corresponds to a modest but non-negligible probability.
Claude modal unlikely [unlikely, unlikely, unlikely, unlikely, unlikely] · stability 1.00
- 1 unlikely 0.92 The assistant assigns a 'relatively low probability—maybe 15-25%' to the event occurring within 12 months, citing significant technical challenges, unresolved engineering problems, and the tight timeline despite SpaceX's progress.
- 2 unlikely 0.85 The assistant explicitly rates this as 'unlikely within 12 months' and identifies significant technical hurdles, particularly bringing back the second stage intact from orbit, which 'hasn't been demonstrated.' While acknowledging SpaceX could 'potentially achieve this in 12 months,' the assistant emphasizes this is 'not a confident prediction' and provides a more realistic estimate of '2025-2026 r
- 3 unlikely 0.85 I'd estimate this at **15-25% likely** within 12 months. The assistant emphasizes that 'fully reusable' and 'intact' set a high bar, and that the 12-month window is tight for iterating through failures and regulatory approvals, with the crux being that partial successes would not meet the strict criteria.
- 4 unlikely 0.85 The assistant explicitly states 'This is unlikely but not impossible' and estimates '~15-25% probability,' identifying that while SpaceX is advancing, 'the technical complexity suggests mid-2024 or later is more realistic' for full recovery of both stages within 12 months.
- 5 unlikely 0.95 The assistant explicitly assesses this as 'unlikely (around 20-30% probability)' within the next 12 months, citing SpaceX Starship's lack of achieved full orbital flight with booster recovery, the strictness of 'fully reusable' requirements, unproven booster catch systems, and a tight 12-month timeline.
Gemini modal somewhat likely [somewhat likely, somewhat likely, somewhat likely, somewhat likely, unlikely] · stability 0.80
- 1 somewhat likely 0.85 The model rates the overall outcome as a 'Plausible "Coin Toss" (~40–50% Chance)' due to technical bottlenecks with second-stage recovery.
- 2 somewhat likely 0.85 The assistant describes the statement as 'plausible, but remains an ambitious coin-toss', assessing the critical bottleneck of recovering the upper stage intact at a moderate 40–50% chance.
- 3 somewhat likely 0.85 The model concludes with 'Probability: Moderate (~30%–50%)', noting that the outcome is 'technically feasible' and 'plausible within 12 months', though challenging.
- 4 somewhat likely 0.85 The answer assesses the probability as 'Moderate (30–45%)' and notes that while it remains a significant challenge, it is 'within the realm of possibility.'
- 5 unlikely 0.95 The answer directly rates the outcome under its conclusion: 'Likelihood: Unlikely to Moderately Low (25–35%) within 12 months.'
Change over time
Moved since the prior run (canon-2026-W45). Gemini: unlikely → somewhat likely. ChatGPT: unlikely → somewhat likely.
Every stance label is a derived judgment over the model's free-text answer, kept auditable against the original transcript in the run's raw data. Method: /methodology.
